Living in community
How big should a village be?

A village that families build to share daily life should be big enough to split the work of running the farm the households share, and small enough that people can know one another. Hutterites, a church whose families farm together, start a new colony once theirs reaches about 30 families (Hutterian Brethren). At Thresh Architects, in Tennessee, we plan villages of about 30 to 50 households, opening with about 30 and adding the rest slowly, so friendships have time to form.

A village needs enough households to share the work, and few enough to know each other
A village has a floor and a ceiling, and it has to be designed to sit between them. The floor is the fewest households that can share the work of running the village farm. A farm has fixed costs, the ones that stay the same however many families share them, so with too few households each family pays too much and does too much of the work. We put the floor at about 30 households.
On a cohousing mailing list in 2002 (cohousing is private homes around shared space), one member who chose a bigger community wrote that "the diversity doesn't get on all our nerves all the time as it would if we were 12 units," meaning 12 homes (Cohousing-L). In a group that small, the same few people's differences wear on everyone.
The ceiling is the most people you can still know well. I once wrote that "as we increase the number of people, we decrease the level to which you know these people," until the place becomes less "my community" and more "something far beyond us." I think that's also when it gets easier to see other members as "they" and not "us," and to look for advantages for your own household over theirs. When I know a neighbor, I'd feel bad making a choice that helps only my family.
With too few households each family pays for and does too much of the work, and with too many, people know each other less, so we design a village to sit between the two.
Hutterites start a new colony at about 30 families, so there's work for everyone

The Hutterites keep their colonies small by starting new ones. "Once a colony reaches about 30 families or around 150 people," their own site says, it begins setting up a new colony, called a daughter colony (Hutterian Brethren). Past that size, they write, "it becomes difficult to find jobs for all the members," and a large colony is harder to manage.
A colony farm manager in Alberta gave a smaller number. He told The Western Producer in 2009 that one reason colonies split once they reach 120 members is to give everyone a job and a sense of purpose, because "everybody wants to have a responsibility or a job, or a reason to do something" (The Western Producer).
The Hutterites, a church whose families farm together, start a new colony at about 30 families, because past that size it gets hard to find jobs for everyone and the colony gets harder to run.
Dunbar's number, about 150, is a size some groups have settled near, and scientists still argue over it
Dunbar's number is about 150 people, the size the researcher R. I. M. Dunbar predicted for human groups and then found in traditional societies. In 1993 he took the pattern that among other primates, the apes and monkeys, species with a larger neocortex, the brain's outer layer, for the size of the rest of their brain live in larger groups, and extended it to people to predict groups of about 148. In the nine traditional societies he had good census counts for, the groups bigger than a camp of 30 to 50 people and smaller than the whole tribe typically numbered 100 to 200 people, and averaged about 148 (Dunbar 1993; the author's preprint).
In 2021, three researchers re-ran Dunbar's prediction with newer data and methods and got what they called "wildly different numbers." Their two main methods gave average group sizes of 69 to 109 and of 16 to 42. The uncertainty around them ran as wide as 4 to 520 people, meaning the figure could fall anywhere in that range, so they concluded that "specifying any one number is futile" (Lindenfors, Wartel and Lind 2021).
The 2021 paper tested only the brain-size prediction, not what groups like the Hutterites actually do, so I use about 150 as a guide to start designing with, never as a limit.
About 150 people, known as Dunbar's number, is a size groups like the Hutterites have settled near, and since scientists still argue over it, I use it as a guide for design, never as a limit.
Counted in households, my working figure for a village is about 30 to 50
My working figure for a village is about 30 to 50 households, and I get there from the people I can know. I don't need to know every member of the village to feel connected to every household, only one or two people from each, probably the parents. I assume the families drawn to this way of life run larger than average, 4 to 6 people to a household, because they tend to have more children. With about 150 as the guide, and room left for the friends and family each member brings from outside, that brings me to about 30 to 50 households.
When I first worked this out, my notes said we must leave room for relationships outside the community "if we are to avoid creating a cult where all outsiders are 'others.'"
I only need to know one or two people in each household to feel connected to it, so with about 150 people as a guide and room left for friends outside, my working figure for a village is about 30 to 50 households.
A close friendship takes more than 200 hours, so we plan for a village to fill slowly

A close friendship takes more than 200 hours together, by the estimate of Jeffrey Hall at the University of Kansas, who studied how many hours it takes to make a friend. In two studies, he surveyed 355 adults who had moved in the past six months, and 112 first-year students at the university who had recently moved there. Putting both studies together, he estimated it takes 40 to 60 hours together to become casual friends, 80 to 100 to become friends, and more than 200 to become good friends (Hall 2018; University of Kansas).
We fill a village slowly because of the hours a new friendship takes. A village that fills every house in a single year asks every family to build all of its friendships in the same season, and nobody has those hours to give all at once, so the village starts out as neighbors who barely know each other.
I think a friendship takes much less time to keep than to make. Once the first households know each other, they have hours free for the families who come next, so we grow a village in phases. Each new phase waits until the village farm has shown, over seasons, that it can feed more families.
A close friendship takes more than 200 hours together to form, so we plan for a village to open with about 30 households and add the next ones in later phases.
A mix of lot sizes keeps a village from filling with one kind of household

We plan small lots and large lots, with cottages among them, so households of different ages and incomes live within a walk of each other. A lot is the piece of land each house sits on. In the village plan I wrote that "nothing sustainable is a monoculture," a farmer's word for a field planted with one crop.
As I see it, a village with only one size of lot fills with one kind of household, the same age and the same income, needing the same things in the same years, and whatever none of those households can do, the whole village can't do either.
We plan a mix of lot sizes and cottages, so households of different ages and incomes live within a walk of each other.
Sources
- Cohousing-L mailing list, "Re: optimum size for a community" (2002)
- Hutterian Brethren, "Daughter Colony"
- Mary MacArthur, "Assigned roles give members sense of purpose," The Western Producer (2009)
- R. I. M. Dunbar, "Coevolution of neocortical size, group size and language in humans," Behavioral and Brain Sciences (1993)
- R. I. M. Dunbar, the same paper, the author's preprint
- Lindenfors, Wartel and Lind, "'Dunbar's number' deconstructed," Biology Letters (2021)
- Jeffrey A. Hall, "How many hours does it take to make a friend?," Journal of Social and Personal Relationships (2018)
- University of Kansas, "How to make friends? Study reveals how many hours it takes" (2018)
Let’s talk