Planning a home on land
Where should I build my house on my land?

Where your land gives you a choice, build the house on higher, drier ground, off the open, level field with the best soil for growing and up out of the low spot where rainwater collects, and plan the drive and daily paths around it. In my view, a house can be designed to fit a gentle slope or step down it among trees, while a field needs the flatter, better ground. Once a house is built on that ground, nothing can be grown there.

In my experience, the easiest ground to build on is usually the best ground to grow on
In my experience, the easiest ground to build on is usually the best ground to farm. It's level and cleared, so its foundations and roads are cheap, and it costs the least in the budget. Crops and grass need that same ground, so what makes it cheap is the same thing that makes it worth keeping. A house built there sits out in the open on cleared ground, and the field under it and its yard can't be grown on again.
The US Department of Agriculture's rule for prime farmland, the land it rates best for growing food, feed and other crops, sets out what that ground is like (7 CFR 657.5). Its soils aren't soaked with water for long stretches, and they flood less often than once in 2 years during the growing season or are protected from flooding. They also don't wash away easily, so a field on a steep slope is less likely to count as prime.
A national study by American Farmland Trust found that between 2001 and 2016, nearly 7 million acres of US farmland and ranchland were turned into low-density, large-lot housing (American Farmland Trust, 2020).
In my experience, the level, cleared ground that's cheapest to build on is usually the best ground for growing, so a house built there uses up the ground most worth keeping.
A house can be fitted to a slope, while a field needs the level ground

Ground that's poor for pasture can still take a house, because in my experience a house is far more flexible than a field in how it meets the land. We can grade the ground, meaning reshape it, or design a house to step down a slope. Where that ground is wooded, the trees already standing there, cleared only where they have to be, become a privacy screen between neighbors. A field is far less flexible, since grass and crops need the level, cleared, well-drained ground.
At Thresh Architects, in Tennessee, when we plan a village, the houses go up on ground the farm can't use, and the farm keeps the best of it. The ground the farm can't use is usually above the fields, on ridges that run fairly flat along the top and are wooded and untouched because they were never much use to a farmer. On a family's acreage, the same thinking means finding the ground you'd grow on and fitting the house somewhere else.
However flexible a house is, the ground right under it should slope gently. Purdue University's soils manual for homesites in Indiana names 2% to 6% as the ideal, a rise of 2 to 6 feet in every 100 feet (Purdue). Where a house has no sewer line, it uses a septic system, a tank and a field of buried pipes that let its wastewater soak into the soil, which cleans it. Past 6%, the manual warns, soil washing away, unstable soil and water seeping from the septic system can become problems.
Fit the house to the higher, wooded ground, on its flatter top or a gentle slope, and leave the level field for growing.
A lush low spot collects the rain, so build above it

Purdue's manual also says a low spot on higher ground usually gathers the water running off the slopes above it, and poorly drained soils are often found there (Purdue). For a house, that can mean a wet basement and a yard you can't use. The manual says a septic system shouldn't go in a low spot, and that houses shouldn't be built on floodplains, the flat ground beside a creek or river that floods.
On 1,000 acres of untouched land, I came to a hollow with a spring that looked like a fairy garden, where I'd have picnics. Even so, "this isn't a build site," I said, because it's a low point that all the rainwater runoff comes down to, and that water is what makes it so lush. The places to build were up on the higher ground above it, and the hollow stays as a place to walk down to and picnic in.
How to spot wet ground on a walk is in What should I look for the first time I walk my land? Before you buy, a few checks can rule a spot out: the flood maps, a perc test and the setbacks. A perc test measures how fast the soil soaks up water, which decides whether a septic system can go there. The setbacks are the rules on how far a house must sit from the road and the property lines.
Keep the house and its septic field out of the low spot where rainwater collects, and build on the higher ground above it.
When more than one spot is good, choose by how you'll live there

When more than one spot is good, which one you pick comes down to how you'll live there. Above that hollow I found two, one on each of two small hills, both with great views. When my time on the land ran out, I said, "it's all preference... we could build a healthy home on any one of these sites."
If you want the morning light, note at each spot whether anything to its east, such as a hill or a tree line, blocks the early sun. I want that light in the house, because it comes after the night has cooled the air and the house, so it isn't hot. Then note what stands to the spot's west, the side of a house I shield most, since the setting sun shines into windows there with heat and glare. Trees on that side, or shading designed into the house itself, can block it. Privacy can decide it too: one client wanted woods at the back "so that there's nobody behind me."
Between good spots, pick the one with the morning light and the privacy you want.
Plan the drive in and the daily paths with the house

Where the house sits also decides how you reach it and how you get around once you're there. Clients have told us they want "a long drive towards the little compound."
In our Cabin Guide, the guide we wrote around our Wild Cabin design, I suggest stretching the walk from where you park to the front door just enough for a few small changes along it, such as a change in paving or a pocket of shade. Even 25 to 40 feet is enough for three of them.
Everyday walks, to the garden or the mailbox, belong in the plan too. A shortcut worn through the grass shows the line people choose when they walk between two places. Right angles look nice on drawings, but people walk the easiest line between the places they go, the way water runs downhill.
Place the house with the drive and the everyday paths in mind.
Sources
- 7 CFR 657.5, "Identification of important farmlands" (prime farmland), Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute
- American Farmland Trust, Farms Under Threat: The State of the States, Executive Summary, 2020
- Purdue University, Indiana Soils: Evaluation and Conservation Online Manual, "Soils and Homesites"
Let’s talk