Let’s talk

Dwell Wild

Health Community Land

ThreshEarlier work of our team
Learn

The ideas behind it

Where do new ideas come from?

Published Oct 9, 2026 · 6 min read

I think new ideas come from the edges, where two different things meet, such as two fields of knowledge or two people who see a problem differently. In nature, where a forest meets a field, the number of kinds of plants may be greatest along the edge between them (Masters, Ditchkoff and Farley). At Thresh Architects, in Tennessee, I see the architect's work as listening to each of the different ideas that meet at those edges and making peace between them.

An open cardboard box with seedlings sprouting along its edges, where two sides meet, and not inside or outside it, because new ideas form along the edges.

Think along the edges of the box, where new ideas form

In my 2019 master's thesis on where innovation comes from, I suggested a change to the advice to think outside the box: "Perhaps it's not thinking outside of the box as much as thinking along the edges of the box." The box stands for any category, any group of things we've learned to see as one kind.

My reason was that "a box is understood by its edges and not its middle." A category is made by where it stops and the next one starts. Red and orange have different names, yet the shades right on the border between them "are classified as different but are nearly identical," and the border is where one category has the most in common with the next. In my thesis I argued that where two categories touch, they act on each other, and what comes of it can fit neither, which is a new idea.

So if you want an idea that's new to your field, look where your field touches another one. I wrote that innovation, or genius, "can be understood as a change in perspective beyond that of an increase in aptitude." It comes more from seeing a problem from a new side than from getting better at the old way of solving it.

A category is defined by its edges, where it touches the next one, and where two categories touch they can make something that fits neither, so I'd look for new ideas along those edges.

Fields of knowledge narrow as they specialize, so two fields meet near their base

Two stepped pyramids of stone, one tan and one gray, narrow to sharp points at the top and touch only at their wide bases, where a small plant sprouts between them.

For a field of knowledge, I swapped the box for "what I believe to be a better geometry for the job, the pyramid." Each field has a broad base of plain definitions that anyone can learn, and it narrows as it becomes more specialized, because each new piece of knowledge is built on the pieces under it.

The higher a field climbs, the more it grows its own language, words only the people in it use. So an expert near the top of one field, where the pyramid is narrow, ends up far from the next field, and shares fewer words with the people working there.

The way across, as I see it, is to come back down. Someone learns one field partway up, comes back down to its plain base, crosses to another field, climbs partway up that one, and brings back an idea from it to use in the first field.

Each field of knowledge narrows as it grows more specialized, so the easiest place to cross from one field to another is near its base, where the words are still plain.

Where a forest meets a field, you can find more kinds of plants

A forest on the left opens onto a grassy field on the right, with a band of wildflowers and young trees growing thick where the two meet.

A fact sheet from the Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service, written for people who manage land for wildlife, says the number of kinds of plants "may be greatest along an edge or transition zone" (Masters, Ditchkoff and Farley). An edge, as the authors use the word, is "the boundary between two different plant communities," such as the line where woods meet a field.

In Gaia's Garden, his book on home gardens, Toby Hemenway wrote that ecologists have a name for what happens at an edge, "the edge effect." He wrote, "Edges are where things happen." Where a forest meets the prairie, he wrote, you find the species that thrive on each side, plus new ones that live in the band between them. In his words, "the edge is richer than what is on either side" (Hemenway, Gaia's Garden).

In my thesis I argued that ideas work the same way: where two fields, or two people who see a problem differently, meet, the ideas of both sit side by side, and sometimes they make a new one that belongs to neither. The fact sheet and Hemenway are about plants and wildlife, so the step from plants to ideas is my own.

Where a forest meets a field, the number of kinds of plants may be greatest along the edge between them.

Cutting something into smaller pieces makes more edge

Cutting something into smaller pieces makes more edge, and so more places where one piece meets another, which is why I used it in my thesis to explain towns built from many small lots. My example was a loaf of bread. The whole loaf has a certain amount of outside surface, and cutting it in half adds two new cut faces to that outside. Each cut after that adds two more faces, so the edge grows one cut at a time while the amount of bread stays the same.

The Oklahoma fact sheet does the same sum for land, showing that "an 80-acre square patch would have 7,467 feet of edge," while two square 40-acre patches, 80 acres in all, would have 10,560 feet.

To people who say that to get more wildlife you should "just increase edge," the authors of the fact sheet answer, "This is not necessarily true." Some animals may gain from living near an edge, they write, and to others an edge doesn't matter or may do harm. When a large forest is cut up into many pieces, the same fact sheet says, it gains edge, and birds that need large unbroken woods, such as the scarlet tanager and the ovenbird, lose out.

Each cut through a loaf or a piece of land adds edge, but cutting a forest into small pieces costs the birds that need deep woods.

A town built by many hands has more edges than one drawn at once

Two town blocks side by side, one packed with many small houses, yards and lanes of different shapes, the other with just two large buildings set on open lawn.

A town made of many small lots, each decided by a different person over many years, has many places where one person's decision meets another's. I put the difference between a planned town and an unplanned one this way: "The Planned is of one mind, and the unplanned is of many minds that do not necessarily agree."

One designer drawing a town all at once works from a single point of view. Of a plan like that, the thesis says, "by definition, there is no innovation, because it is prescribed, meaning it exists already."

"An unplanned development is actually planned, but at a much smaller scale and of many more perspectives," I wrote, each person planning a small piece. On the choice between the planned town and the unplanned one, "I'd argue that the solution is neither, but somewhere in-between their boundaries."

Many people building over years make more edges than one designer drawing a town at once, and I'd look for the best way to plan a town somewhere between the two.

Friction between two different ideas is what makes something new

I wrote that "friction is the touching of two separate things," and that without it "we would have absolutely no interaction" between them. When two different ideas meet, it is the friction between them that causes "a new boundary to form around that relationship," meaning what they make together becomes a new kind of thing, with edges of its own.

Friction is where two different things touch, and without it two ideas would never push on each other and make something new.

An architect's job is to make peace between different ideas

The thesis ends its argument with the architect: "The Architect is the peace maker between definitions." I described the work as "an approach to listen, instead of speak." When different people bring different ideas of what a place should be, the architect steps in between them and listens to each.

I talk with scientists who work in other fields about their research, and I bring what I learn from them back into our architecture.

I see the architect as a peacemaker between different ideas, who listens to each of them and works where they meet.

Sources

  1. Ron Masters, Steve Ditchkoff and Stephanie C. Farley, "Edge and Other Wildlife Concepts," Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service, fact sheet L-276
  2. Toby Hemenway, Gaia's Garden: A Guide to Home-Scale Permaculture (quoted words checked in the first edition)