Let’s talk

Dwell Wild

Health Community Land

ThreshEarlier work of our team
Learn

The ideas behind it

Why does every new house look the same?

Published Oct 21, 2026 · 7 min read

Most new houses in the US are built by a builder to sell, and a magazine for home builders advises them to build "fewer floor plans with fewer options." The oldest houses of each region were built from what was at hand and shaped by its weather, so they looked different from one region to the next. At Thresh Architects, in Tennessee, we try each design on its own land and reshape it until it fits that land and the family who'll live there.

A new subdivision seen from above, the same few house plans repeated along a street, built to sell on land cleared of trees and leveled to fit.

Most new houses are built to sell, by builders advised to repeat a few plans

Of about 1,005,000 new single-family houses finished in the US in 2025, about 721,000, roughly 7 in 10, were built for sale (US Census Bureau, Table Q6), with the builder selling the house and its lot together in what the Census Bureau calls "one transaction" (US Census Bureau, definitions). About 130,000, roughly 1 in 8, were built for the owner of the land by a contractor. In the South, where Tennessee is, about 3 in 4 were built for sale (US Census Bureau, Table Q9). These tables sort houses by why they were built, so they can't tell us how many repeat a plan.

A column in Professional Builder, a magazine for home builders, advises "fewer floor plans with fewer options," because "reusing proven floor plans enables everyone involved to advance up the learning curve," meaning everyone involved gets more efficient at a plan they've built before (Professional Builder). That's advice, with no count of how many builders follow it.

People call houses built from the same few plans cookie-cutter houses, after the cutter that stamps every cookie in one shape. In a 2006 KPBS story about look-alike houses in San Diego, a UC San Diego urban planning teacher said, "Everyone lives in the same four or five plans" (KPBS).

Most new houses are built to sell, and builders are advised to keep to a few plans, because, the column says, everyone gets more efficient at a plan they've built before.

The oldest houses of each region were built from what was at hand, for its weather

Four old regional houses, each built from what was at hand for its weather: a log house with a breezeway, an adobe with thick earth walls, a raised house with a wide porch, and a saltbox with its long roof to the north wind.

The houses of the Indigenous peoples of North America were, as I said in our video "Your Home's Real Job (It's Not What You Think)", "totally different from bio region to bio region," meaning from one region's land and climate to the next.

  • Adobe, in the desert Southwest, is sun-dried brick, and "traditionally, adobe bricks were never kiln fired," or baked in an oven (National Park Service).
  • A wigwam, which Merriam-Webster calls "a hut used by Indigenous American peoples of the Great Lakes region and eastward," usually has arched poles covered with bark, mats or hides (Merriam-Webster).
  • The Haudenosaunee, or Iroquois, built the longhouse, which I called "hoop houses." They framed it with "poles and saplings that are able to bend to allow for rain and snow removal," covered it in elm bark, and built a second frame outside the bark so it "was strong enough to withstand north east winters" (Onondaga Nation).

Architects call this vernacular building, the way ordinary people built in one place with what was there, for its weather and ground. As I wrote in our plans for a village, "Every region has buildings that have stood long enough to show what belongs there, the old farmhouses and barns built from what was at hand and shaped by the weather they had to stand up to."

The oldest houses of each region were built from what was at hand and shaped by its weather, so a desert house and a house in the snowy Northeast looked nothing alike.

Look-alike houses go back more than a century, to the railroad

Workers unload numbered, pre-cut lumber from two boxcars onto a horse cart at a rail depot while the same house goes up in a row beside the track, one plan shipped anywhere.

More than a century ago, trains began to bring the same materials and the same house designs to many places. The National Park Service's guide to old adobe buildings says the roofs of early adobe buildings "were flat, made with mud, with low parapets," the low walls around a roof's edge. "After the railroad reached the Southwest, hip roofs and wooden trim began to appear as sawn lumber, shingles, tile, and sheet metal became available" (National Park Service).

A hip roof slopes down on all four sides. Those new materials came in by train, so adobe houses there began to be roofed and trimmed with materials from far away.

Whole houses came by train too. From 1908 to 1940, Sears, Roebuck and Co. sold about 70,000 to 75,000 houses by mail, in 447 designs. Each was shipped to the nearest train depot in one or two boxcars with up to 30,000 pieces of lumber, and "every piece of lumber was numbered and pre-cut to fit into its place in the house" (Hagley Museum and Library). So the same designs went up wherever Sears shipped them.

I think a lot of the sameness came from people bringing the architecture of the places they came from and having "sort of imposed it" here. With the industrialization of so many things, "we've kind of removed the geographic relevancy" of them, meaning how they fit their place, "which happened in architecture, too."

Houses built from the same designs go back more than a century, to when trains brought sawn lumber to the Southwest and Sears shipped its 447 house designs to the nearest train depot.

One way of designing draws the whole house first and sets it on any lot

The pyramid and the labyrinth are a pair from design theory. In 1975 the architect Bernard Tschumi used the pyramid for architecture as "a thing of the mind" and the labyrinth for architecture known through "the senses" (Studio International). In the video I used the pair this way: my pyramid is a design worked out whole in the mind, with nothing taken from the place where it will stand, "this perfectly idealized geometric form." You "plop it down... like a McDonald's," and "it's the same everywhere else."

A house plan built on lot after lot is that kind of design, one drawn for no place in particular.

My labyrinth is "entirely responsive," a maze, a design worked out one step at a time in response to the place, with no picture of the whole house to start from. It's "like being blindfolded and trying to feel around for... the walls and the next step so that way you don't run into something," trying to get "100% context," taking in everything about the place. Feeling your way like that is slow, and "that's not the most efficient way to design something." And the pyramid, which takes nothing from the place, "is not the most contextually responsible way to design something."

A plan drawn whole in the mind can be built the same on every lot, whatever slope or sun that lot has.

We set each piece of a design on the land and reshape it until the house fits

A hand sets small wooden blocks onto a contoured model of the land one piece at a time, reshaping them around the trees and the angle of the sun, with sketches of the house beside it.

I draw one piece of the house, set it on the site, learn from the site what I didn't know, such as where the trees stand or the angle of the sun, reshape the piece, and add the next one, "like building blocks." Drawing each piece whole is the pyramid's half, and reshaping it to the site is the labyrinth's, so I work between the two. In the same video I described it as "idealizing maybe units of design and then recontextualizing them and then gathering that data and then reiterating on that." How I find a design through many tries is in How do architects come up with designs?.

The house has to fit two things at once. In What makes a house a home? I describe the family and the land as two puzzle pieces, each with its own shape, and the house as a new piece made to fit both. The family's shape comes from things like its routines and values, and the land's from things like its slope and the angle of the sun.

"Too many homes feel like they were just dropped on a property," I say in the video we made to welcome new clients. "We try to make ours feel like they emerged from it."

We set one piece of the design on the land, learn what we didn't know about it, reshape the piece and add the next, until the house fits that land and that family.

I didn't want Thresh to have one look, because each house should come from its own land and family

When I started Thresh, I decided, as I said in my 2026 talk The Architecture of Creation, that "I didn't want this firm to be defined by... a characteristic look." A signature look, the kind that lets you name a firm from one of its buildings, would mean to me that "it's way too egotistical and it's like I haven't listened enough to the context" (the land and the place around the house).

I want each house grounded in its land so fully that "you can't really see like oh that's Zach's design." Then "you're looking at it, you're like that looks like it belongs there and it's always been there. And that's the signature."

The look I want for a house is the one that makes people say it belongs on its land and has always been there, so I didn't want Thresh to have a look of its own.

Sources

  1. US Census Bureau, Survey of Construction, "Comparing New Home Sales and New Residential Construction"
  2. US Census Bureau and HUD, New Residential Construction, Tables Q6 and Q9, new privately owned housing units completed by purpose and design, for the United States and by region, released Aug 18 2026
  3. Tony Callahan, "How to Improve Home Building Productivity, Part 1", Professional Builder, 2023
  4. Joanne Faryon, "Home identity crisis brewing in San Diego", KPBS, 2006
  5. "Your Home's Real Job (It's Not What You Think)", Thresh Architects | Wild Dwelling on YouTube
  6. National Park Service, Preservation Brief 5, "Preservation of Historic Adobe Buildings"
  7. Merriam-Webster, "wigwam"
  8. Onondaga Nation, "Ganoñhsésgeh: Longhouse"
  9. Linda Gross, "Published Collections: 'Home Sweet Home' by Mail Order", Hagley Museum and Library, 2014
  10. Bernard Tschumi, "Questions of Space: The Pyramid and the Labyrinth (or the Architectural Paradox)", Studio International, 1975
  11. Zachary Correa, "The Architecture of Creation", Thresh Architects | Wild Dwelling on YouTube (recorded July 23, 2026)